Franken, Coleman fight narrow race

U.S. Sen. Norm Coleman and Democratic challenger Al Franken waited for returns into Wednesday morning as the two battled in Minnesota's high-profile Senate race.

U.S. Sen. Norm Coleman and Democratic challenger Al Franken waited for returns into Wednesday morning as the two battled in Minnesota's high-profile Senate race.

Coleman led his Democratic opponent 931,513 (42 percent) to 912,511 (41 percent) with 80 percent of precincts reporting. The Independence Party's Dean Barkley trailed with 338,263 votes (15 percent).

Both candidates braced for a long night, as they traded leads in early ballot returns. Around 11:30 p.m., Coleman and Franken told their supporters to keep their hopes up for another several hours.

"Give the folks a few more hours to finish counting, then we'll hope to give you six years of standing up for what's right," Franken told supporters in St. Paul.

Franken said Minnesota sent a powerful message by helping to elect Barack Obama president.


"And tonight I'm humbled and I'm grateful and I can't wait to help President-elect Barack Obama get this country back on its feet again," Franken said before midnight.

Coleman was optimistic.

"There is more counting to be done," Coleman told Republicans gathered in Bloomington. "Save your energy. Keep being hopeful. I'm feeling very good right now."

Barkley, who had trailed significantly in recent polls, had hoped for an election-night surprise, but just before midnight said he would eventually concede to the winner.

"This has been a great fight," Barkley said. "I'm proud of everything we've done."

Democratic-Farmer-Labor Party Chairman Brian Melendez said the fact that Barack Obama won the presidential contest would help Franken, he, too, predicted it would be a long night.

Republicans liked Coleman's chances.

"The marquee (race) of the evening is going to be Norm's re-election," state GOP Chairman Ron Carey said.


Minnesotans who faced an onslaught of negative campaign advertising in recent weeks flocked to the polls to settle Minnesota's most high-profile contest - and one of the most-watched in the country.

Coleman and Franken, who had spent an estimated $40 million between them, entered Election Day trading small leads in independent polls. Neither could establish an edge, leaving them in a virtual tie in the closing days of a long campaign.


The race, rife with nasty campaign advertisements from both candidates as well as outside groups, got increasingly ugly in the closing weeks. Coleman's campaign said in mid-October it was ending its negative ads, and later filed a campaign complaint alleging Franken included false statements about the senator in two television advertisements. An administrative law judge Monday threw out half of the complaint, but agreed to hear arguments on the remainder of the complaint today.

In the campaign's last week, Coleman was dogged by allegations in two lawsuits claiming a wealthy Coleman friend tried to funnel $100,000 of corporate funds to the senator through a firm that contracts with his wife.

Coleman said the allegations were false and described them as a last-minute attack by Franken. The Democrat insisted he had nothing to do with the allegations and said it was Coleman's problem.

Barkley hoped the nasty Coleman-Franken exchanges would benefit him.

Besides the three major candidates, voters also could choose from Charles Aldrich of the Libertarian Party or the Constitution Party's James Niemackl. Neither ran a visible statewide campaign.


Coleman's re-election theme was that he has a record of accomplishment in the Senate as well as the experience and temperament required to work with both Republicans and Democrats.

"It's not what you talk about, it's what you do," he said.

Franken often repeated his campaign mantra that he would fight for middle-class Minnesotans in the Senate and that Coleman had sided with corporate interests and the unpopular Bush administration.

"I want to act, that's why I'm running for Senate," Franken said. "But it's about who you're acting on behalf of."

A Republican in a traditionally Democratic-leaning state, Coleman was seeking another six-year term. The first-term senator entered this year's contest familiar with unpredictable elections, both as victor and loser.

Then a two-term St. Paul mayor, Coleman ran for governor in 1998 and ended up a victim of Jesse Ventura's third-party election surprise. Coleman returned to the ballot in 2002 as the GOP Senate candidate, having been the Bush administration's preferred candidate.

Coleman was challenging Democratic U.S. Sen. Paul Wellstone when, when less than two weeks before the election, Wellstone died in a campaign airplane crash. Former Vice President Walter Mondale was picked to run in place of Wellstone, and Coleman beat Mondale in the GOP-friendly 2002 mid-term election.

Coleman fashioned himself a moderate Republican who generally sided with the Bush administration and conservatives on judicial appointments and military policy, but was willing to buck his party when its policies were not in the best interest of Minnesota. An example, he said, was his votes to overturn Bush vetoes of a new farm bill.


In his first run for public office, Franken won over party activists and secured the Democratic endorsement. But in the process, he suffered a number of self-inflicted gaffes and may have underestimated the extent to which the GOP would try to build a case against him. They provided evidence he failed to provide worker's compensation insurance to employees and did not pay income taxes properly.

State Capitol reporter Don Davis and free-lance writer Julie Bartkey contributed to this story.

What To Read Next
Get Local