Protest erupts over Minn. high school yearbook comment saying student 'would like to behead' Trump

Body: 
A comment made by a Brainerd (Minn.) High School student in the 2016-17 yearbook generated sizable controversy on social media in the past day. Brainerd Dispatch Illustration

A violent comment about President Donald Trump made by a Brainerd High School student in the 2016-17 yearbook has people asking how the comment made it into the yearbook.

One page of the yearbook asks students for their feelings about Trump. One of the four commenters, a sophomore, had harsh words for the president.

"I would like to behead him," the student said. "I do not like him."

Shelley Hansch heard about the page from her daughter, who attends BHS. Hansch was astonished when she saw the page, she said, and couldn't believe the district would allow the comments to be printed.

"I couldn't believe that there were no checks and balances," Hansch said. "Somebody approved it."

Hansch was one of about 40-50 people who gathered at Mickey's Pizza and Subs Friday afternoon across the street from BHS. The impromptu rally included a mix of community members and students. Some of the community members ended up in a shouting argument with a group of students who expressed support for the school district.

Someone should lose their job because of the lack of oversight, Hansch said, and someone needs to be held accountable.

"I can't believe the entire thing was run by students," Hansch said. "I can't believe that it could have gone through print without it going through the proper channels."

Ultimately, the situation makes the school look bad, Hansch said. Politics don't belong in a public school yearbook, she said.

"The question shouldn't have been asked," Hansch said. "The whole page should have been wiped out."

Jake Berg, a senior at BHS, said he heard about the yearbook page on Facebook and looked at it in a friend's yearbook. The comments were biased and shouldn't have been in the yearbook, he said.

"I don't believe beheading anybody and putting it in a yearbook should be in there," Berg said. "No matter if it was Trump, (Hillary) Clinton or (Barack) Obama."

If similar comments had been made about Obama or Clinton, the comments would have been labeled as racist or sexist, Berg said, and been removed from the yearbook.

"If you would have said something like that to another student, you probably would have reaped the consequences," Berg said. "And they probably would have been pretty hefty."

Berg doesn't have a problem with the school district, he said, but he does have a problem with the comments ending up in the yearbook.

"Someone made a mistake," Berg said. "I think they should have been more careful about what they put in there."

On Friday afternoon, the school district released the following statement on its website: "The administration of Brainerd Public Schools has been notified that the 2016-2017 high school yearbook contains highly disrespectful statements from students about political figures, including the president of the United States. The administration was previously unaware of the students' statements in the yearbook. The district does not support or otherwise endorse any disrespectful or politically based statements that are in the yearbook and apologizes for the statements that were included. While the district supports free speech, the disrespectful statements in the yearbook are contrary to the basic educational mission of the district and should not have been included in a school sponsored publication. The administration is currently investigating how this occurred and is reviewing the district's processes to ensure that this type of unacceptable situation does not occur in the future. The administration deeply regrets that the existing processes for reviewing the yearbook did not result in the removal of the inappropriate statements."

The BHS yearbook features grades 9-12 and is put together by students in a yearbook class. The yearbook adviser is Joe Wagner, who did not return calls for comment Friday. Superintendent Laine Larson said Friday she did not know what the existing editing process is for the yearbook, and the district would be investigating the process.

Yearbook costs range from $50-$60 depending on when students order the books. If a family or a student would like to return their yearbook, the district will refund their money, Larson said.

Sen. Carrie Ruud, R-Breezy Point, said by phone from St. Paul she has been inundated with calls from parents wanting to know more about the situation. It was careless for school employees to allow those comments to run in the yearbook, Ruud said. The student's name will now be synonymous with those comments, she said.

"They should be protected, it's pretty ridiculous," Ruud said. "How did a teacher or adviser think that's OK?"

The student's comment about Trump is outrageous, Ruud said, and an adult should have told the student a comment like that is not appropriate.

"Do we teach our children that that's an OK comment?" Ruud said.

Mark Johnson, assistant special agent in charge with the U.S. Secret Service field office in Minneapolis, confirmed the agency was aware of the comment and was investigating. Johnson said he could not comment on the agency's investigative practices, but agents may come to the city where the threat originated as part of its investigation.

A poll graphic on the page asks "Do you like Trump?" It's not clear how many students responded to the poll, but the "No" responses outweigh the "Yes" responses. It's not clear what the margin is between the two or how the poll was conducted.

On Oct. 25, 2016, BHS students joined students throughout the state in casting ballots for president, as part of the Students Vote program sponsored by the Minnesota Secretary of State. Trump won that straw poll at BHS, by a margin of 688 votes to 397 votes over Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton.